Cam Schlittler won the 2026 American League Cy Young Award unanimously on Wednesday, November 11, after leading the league with a 1.95 earned run average in his first full major-league season. The New York Yankees right-hander received all 30 first-place votes from the Baseball Writers’ Association of America. Toronto Blue Jays starter Dylan Cease finished second, Cleveland Guardians left-hander Parker Messick was third and Tampa Bay Rays starter Drew Rasmussen placed fourth. Schlittler is the seventh Yankees pitcher to receive the award and the third to do so unanimously, joining Ron Guidry in 1978 and Gerrit Cole in 2023.
The vote recognized a season with a low rate of run scoring and a substantial workload. Schlittler took the ball for 33 starts, worked 193⅔ innings and struck out 239 hitters. He finished 14–6 with a 0.92 WHIP, which counts hits and walks allowed per inning. Most revealingly for a team trying to win on the days he pitched, he allowed one run or none in 21 starts, the highest total in the majors according to MLB. His award case came from producing that kind of outing repeatedly across the schedule.
What a unanimous ballot does and does not measure
Each of the 30 American League voters ranked five pitchers. A first-place vote was worth seven points, followed by four, three, two and one for the remaining places. Schlittler’s 30 firsts produced the maximum of 210 points. Cease received 22 second-place votes and finished on 110 points. Messick took seven second-place votes and 84 points, while Rasmussen earned the remaining second-place vote and 72 points. All four were named on every ballot. The consensus at the top therefore coexisted with a clear difference in how individual writers ranked the next three pitchers.
The ballots were submitted before postseason play. That distinction matters because some of the most memorable innings of Schlittler’s young career were pitched in October, and he added to that record again in 2026. The Cy Young ballot judged what voters had seen over the regular season. A performance in an elimination game can explain why the public remembers a pitcher, but it cannot explain votes already cast. The regular-season award tells us how broadly the writers agreed on his body of work before the playoff matchups had produced their own results.
How 193⅔ innings turned a rate into a season
Earned run average expresses the number of earned runs a pitcher allows per nine innings. It gives pitchers with different workloads a common scale. A rate of 1.95 over 193⅔ innings describes how rarely opponents scored earned runs across the volume of work expected of a frontline starter. Those innings also represent 581 outs. In baseball’s official score displays, the notation 193.2 means 193 innings plus two outs, so it should be read as 193⅔ innings rather than as a decimal.
The workload helps explain why the 14–6 win-loss record only tells part of the story. Schlittler had a decision in 20 of 33 starts, leaving 13 with neither a win nor a loss charged to him. A starter can limit scoring while his own lineup struggles, or leave a lead that changes hands later. ERA summarizes the earned runs attributed to the pitcher, while WHIP offers an additional view of how often hitters reached through a hit or a walk. Schlittler allowed 129 hits and 49 walks. Across his full innings total those figures produce the 0.92 WHIP listed in his official statistics.
Strikeouts add a third layer. His 239 tied Cease for second in the American League behind Gavin Williams of Cleveland, who struck out 248. That works out to approximately 11.1 strikeouts per nine innings for Schlittler. An out on strikes generally removes the fielders and the placement of a batted ball from the equation. A pitcher can also limit runs by controlling contact, and the 1.95 ERA should not be reduced to the strikeout count. In Schlittler’s case the combination of a high strikeout total and relatively few baserunners explains why opponents had so few chances to assemble an inning.
The road split makes that record even more instructive. MLB reported a 1.16 road ERA for Schlittler and a .153 batting average for opponents in those games. The full-season average already covers different parks and opponents, but the away numbers show that a sizable part of the run prevention came in other clubs’ ballparks. They also put the 21 starts with one run or fewer in context. The Yankees received low-scoring innings from him through much of a schedule that moved between home and road.
Cease and Messick put the gap in perspective
Cease matched Schlittler’s 239 strikeouts in just 169 innings. The Toronto right-hander therefore generated about 12.7 strikeouts per nine innings, a higher rate than the winner’s. He made 29 starts with a 2.40 ERA in his first season with the Blue Jays, and the vote gave him his second Cy Young runner-up finish after placing second with the White Sox in 2022. That is a useful comparison because it shows what Schlittler’s campaign had to offer against a different kind of statistical case. Cease missed bats at a greater rate. Schlittler logged 24⅔ more innings while allowing fewer earned runs per nine.
Messick supplied another form of competition. The Cleveland rookie posted a 2.56 ERA with 193 strikeouts over 186⅓ innings in 32 starts. His season came after seven major-league starts in 2025. He reached the final ballot discussion with a workload close to Schlittler’s, and seven writers placed him second. Rasmussen’s presence on every ballot further shows that support extended beyond the finalists. The writers agreed on the winner, with a separate judgment about how to weigh workload, strikeouts and run prevention behind him.
From Somerset to a full turn in the Yankees’ rotation
New York selected Schlittler from Northeastern University in the seventh round of the 2022 draft. He earned South Atlantic League Pitcher of the Year honors with Hudson Valley in 2024, then opened 2025 at Double-A Somerset and moved up to Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre before his major-league debut on July 9. His first stretch with the Yankees brought a 2.96 ERA over 14 regular-season starts. It gave the club a credible young starter before his 2026 performance supplied the more demanding evidence of a full season.
The archival photograph accompanying this article shows Schlittler with Somerset in April 2025, months before his major-league debut. The progression through the organization was especially compressed that year. Double-A and Triple-A are separate levels, and the major-league assignment put him in a rotation facing deeper lineups and more frequent repeat encounters. The increase from 14 major-league regular-season starts in 2025 to 33 in 2026 meant more opportunities for opponents to adjust, as well as more chances for him to demonstrate that his run prevention would hold up.
An early demonstration of his ability to carry a high-stakes start came in the deciding game of the 2025 Wild Card Series against Boston. He pitched eight scoreless innings with 12 strikeouts and no walks as the Yankees won 4–0. MLB reported that he was the first pitcher to combine at least eight scoreless innings, at least 12 strikeouts and no walks in a postseason appearance. That night helped establish the reputation. The 2026 Cy Young recognizes how often he gave New York dependable innings over the following regular season.
The Boston game also provides a concrete illustration of how he could vary his approach while pitching at high velocity. MLB’s pitch-tracking breakdown counted 96 fastballs of various kinds among his 107 pitches that night. That group included four-seamers, sinkers and cutters. Each can arrive quickly, but the trajectories diverge. A sinker can move more toward the pitcher’s arm side, while a cutter moves in the opposite direction relative to a straight fastball. For the batter, the task involves identifying both the pitch’s direction and the time available to put the barrel on it.
That 2025 mix is evidence from one documented start, rather than a season-level claim about what he threw in 2026. It helps explain why velocity on a scoreboard is only part of the difficulty. When pitches approach at similar speeds but finish in different places, a hitter who commits to one path can miss another. The regular-season totals show the outcome over a much larger sample. Schlittler paired 239 strikeouts with 49 walks, or nearly five strikeouts for every walk. That balance matters because the value of avoiding contact diminishes if a pitcher gives away too many trips to first base.
What the Yankees’ historical comparison can tell us
The first Yankees pitcher on the Cy Young list was Bob Turley in 1958, followed by Whitey Ford in 1961. Sparky Lyle won in 1977, Guidry in 1978, Roger Clemens in 2001 and Cole in 2023. The earliest two awards on that list were handed out when there was a single major-league winner. Separate American and National League awards were introduced in 1967. The franchise list therefore connects pitchers from different voting systems as well as different periods of the game. Schlittler joined it by sweeping the ballot for his own league.
The Associated Press put his 1.95 ERA third among qualifying seasons in Yankees history behind Spud Chandler’s 1.64 in 1943 and Guidry’s 1.74 in 1978. Chandler’s season came before the award existed, so the club’s ERA ranking and its list of Cy Young winners tell related but distinct stories. The ranking puts Schlittler alongside seasons that limited scoring in very different eras. The ballot supplies a comparison within 2026, against pitchers facing the same broad league environment and appearing on the same set of voters’ forms.
For the Yankees, the immediate value of Schlittler’s season was the number of games in which he kept the opponent’s scoring down while taking a regular place in the rotation. The postseason outing against Boston in 2025 showed what he could do in one game. A 1.95 ERA over 33 starts in 2026 shows how many times he gave his club that kind of chance. On November 11, the voting made the distinction official: every writer ranked his regular season first in the American League.
Sources and photo credit
BBWAA voting results · MLB award report · Associated Press via The Washington Post · Schlittler’s official player record · Official finalist profiles · Yankees Magazine on Schlittler’s development · 2025 Wild Card game report · Pitch-tracking analysis of the 2025 Boston start · Cy Young history and winners
Archive photograph from April 17, 2025, by Jeffrey Hyde via Wikimedia Commons, licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0. Displayed from a resized copy without cropping.
Talal Osman




